-
- August 10th, 2006
- 2 Comments »
- Design
Dud on arrival: why important buildings flop (Slate)
Slate has a nice slide show by the famed architecture critic Witold_Rybczynski about major works of architecture that were big failures. It’s a good runthrough of some large scale works, with Cliff’s notes like commentary from Rybczynski on where things went wrong.
I don’t agree with his opinions on some (I’ve been to half of them): EMP is ugly, but still breathtaking. The Montreal stadium is a functional failure, but has amazing aesthetics, and the Getty museum rocks a free escape from the USA, a magic otherworldly garden up on a huge hill, looking down on LA.
I wonder what a slide show of greatest software duds might include? And what would we say about each one?
2 Responses
- Scott (admin) - August 10, 2006 at 11:24 pm #
-
Yes – I mean I was in Montreal once, when I was 14, and I *still* remember seeing the stadium. How can it be a flop if it left that much of an impression on an idiot teenager with zero interest in architecture?
SCOTT'S NEW BOOK
A provocative collection of behind-the-scenes tales from the life of a successful public speaker, bestselling business author Scott Berkun offers a unique insider's take on what public speakers do, how they do it, and how anyone can do it well. Book Details
OTHER BESTSELLERS
Don't miss anything - Free Newsletter
Receive short, near-monthly emails with new essays, most popular posts, and occasional big announcements. Not cheezy - it's good, funny and concise. (privacy policy here)
I lived in Montreal for a few years and I would go to the Olympic Stadium at least once a year. I couldn’t help it, the building had a draw, a presence that screamed former glory.